Hope vs. Hype V: The DeSantis Blueprint and the Donalds Doodle
Despite what the populists will tell you, governing isn’t a performance. It’s not a podcast, a panel, or a parade of slogans. It’s planning. It’s presence. And it’s knowing the difference between a policy document and a coloring book.
Our subject today: Byron Donalds. His defenders say he’s the future. I say he’s a walking soundbite in search of a state to ruin.
There are those who rise to meet the moment—and those who ask if the moment comes with stage lights and a sponsor.
As Florida’s political class begins its ritualistic murmuring over the next gubernatorial contest—a year early, mind you—one name keeps floating into the conversation like a helium balloon tied to a policy pamphlet: Byron Donalds.
His advocates assure us he’s charismatic. Energetic. A rising star. But then again, so was the Hindenburg—right up until impact.
Byron Donalds: Cargo Cult Conservatism in a Suit
Donalds has made a career out of saying things loudly and remembering none of them. His followers, trained in the ancient religion of cargo cult conservatism, believe that if you appear on enough cable segments and retweet enough slogans, the gods of governance will descend and hand you a state to manage.
Florida, unfortunately, is not a state that can be managed with hashtags and half-finished thoughts.
It is a state routinely mauled by hurricanes, floods, insurance meltdowns, and crocodilian opportunists (the political kind, not the reptilian). It demands a steady hand, a coherent sentence, and—at the very least—a functional understanding of how to turn the lights on in the Emergency Operations Center.
To place Byron Donalds next to the DeSantises isn’t just an unfair comparison. It’s an indictment.
Ron: A Governor Before the Governorship
When Ron DeSantis arrived in Congress, he wasn’t there to preen for MSNBC panels or find a Netflix documentary crew. He was there to write, to vote, and to govern—a concept now considered either quaint or suspect, depending on your level of social media addiction.
He co-founded the House Freedom Caucus, yes—but not as a performance artist. He was the annoying kind of conservative: the one who actually read the continuing resolution, marked it up, and offered floor amendments that made his colleagues shift in their seats.
When Ron DeSantis first ran for governor, there was skepticism. But it was philosophical, not practical.
He had the résumé: Yale, Harvard Law, Naval officer, legal advisor in Iraq. He spoke with clipped precision and the intensity of a man who’d memorized footnotes for sport. Even in Congress, he projected the bearing of someone who could conduct a press briefing, lead a staff meeting, and clean up after a hurricane—often before breakfast.
To some, he was “too serious.” Translation: he was prepared.
You may not have agreed with every policy. You may have found his demeanor sharp-edged or unwilling to do the emotional jazz hands modern politics rewards. But the man showed up. And when crisis hit—pandemic, storm, bureaucracy—he governed. Whenever crisis came to Florida one could be sure that DeSantis was on top of it. Even the opposition media couldn’t help but admit it.
Even his enemies—especially his enemies—understood that he was serious. Not flamboyant. Not emotional. Serious. The kind of man who could be left alone in a hurricane briefing room and, upon your return, would have already drawn the evacuation routes in dry-erase marker.
And therein lies the crucial point. DeSantis didn’t gain authority from holding office. He brought authority to the office. He spoke with the posture of a man who had weighed the burden of command—and, crucially, had no desire to Instagram it.
You might not have liked his tone. You might have found him too clipped, too analytical, too devoid of soft edges. But that was the point. He wasn’t trying to be liked—he was trying to prepare. He didn’t rehearse the part of governor. He assumed the duties, long before the press pass got laminated.
Compare that to the current crop of would-be governors, whose idea of leadership involves uploading shirtless gym selfies and debating property taxes as if they were debating who gets aux cord rights on a road trip.
Ron DeSantis was the antidote to all of that before we even knew the disease.
He projected order. He projected command. And in a state like Florida—where the difference between competence and chaos can be measured in flooded roads and blown transformers—that projection wasn’t just comforting. It was necessary.
And now, a few years and several storms later, we know it wasn’t just projection
Byron: The Soundbite Candidate
Now we turn, reluctantly, to Byron Donalds. A man who may be better suited to host a Twitch stream than to govern a state.
His record is as light as a Wiffle ball and half as durable. Ask him about property taxes and you’ll get a verbal shrug dressed in soundbites. Ask him about hurricane preparedness and he’ll say he’s “still studying the issue.” Ask him anything else, and odds are the answer ends with: “We’re gonna fight back!”
Against whom, Byron? Hurricanes?
He lacks executive experience, legislative depth, and worst of all—temperament. Where DeSantis brought military bearing and a lawyer’s command of detail to the podium, Donalds brings the energy of a man trying to remember lines for a part he thought he already had.
Byron Donalds doesn’t want to lead Florida. He wants to inherit it—like a trust fund he thinks he’s earned just by showing up.
He speaks in slogans. The kind embroidered on grift merch and shouted from the stage moments before the fire marshal starts checking capacity. “We’re gonna fight!” “Take back our state!” “The people are fed up!”—yes, yes, and yet none of that has anything to do with evacuation routes, insurance solvency, or debris clearance.
He fancies himself a fighter. But for what? Power? Attention? A podcast deal? All noble pursuits, perhaps. None of them qualify a man to manage a state.
Let’s run the résumé, shall we?
Executive experience? None.
Crisis management record? None.
Major legislation? Nothing of substance.
Policy initiative with measurable results? Don’t be ridiculous.
Demonstrated leadership in a natural disaster? Does appearing on Newsmax count?
Now, what he does have is a communications team. And it shows. Because every time he speaks, it sounds like he’s delivering a line someone else wrote for him. A line they wrote in the car on the way to the event. A line that ends not with a policy point but with a grin—and a hope that the applause comes before the follow-up question.
Byron Donalds is not a serious person pretending to be a performer. He’s a performer pretending to be a serious person. And he’s just hoping no one notices before the ballots are printed.
And look, we’ve seen this type before. The candidate who thinks politics is theater, and leadership is whatever plays well in a 12-second clip. But the difference is—Florida is not a theater. It’s a state on the edge of crisis at nearly all times. It’s a place where hurricanes don’t care if you’ve got charisma. It needs someone who can manage the disaster—not narrate it.
The tragic comedy of it all is that Donalds seems to think the job of governor is something he can grow into. That if you just hand him the keys, he’ll figure it out on the way to Tallahassee. What he fails to understand is: governors don’t grow into the role. They grow the role to meet the moment.
And at this rate, Byron Donalds couldn’t grow a tomato plant with a full set of instructions and a state agriculture grant.Casey: Grace. Grit. Governance.
And then there’s Casey.
Officially, Florida’s First Lady. Unofficially, Florida’s Other Problem Solver.
While Byron poses, Casey plans. During hurricanes, she’s not staging photo ops—she’s coordinating logistics, speaking directly to families, crafting relief networks, and linking nonprofits to actual people in need.
Her initiative—Hope Florida—has done what federal programs only dream of: moved people from dependency to purpose and saved the state money. She didn’t do this from a podcast studio. She didn’t wait for applause. She just got to work.
She governed—without governing.
No oath. No title. No waiting around for permission. She simply led.
Her fingerprints are on Florida’s resilience, its social reintegration systems, its disaster response pipelines. And not because she asked to be credited. Because she’s done the work.
While Byron Donalds is still rehearsing, Casey DeSantis has already performed—with clarity, calm, and results.
Executive experience? Hope Florida, which coordinated nonprofits, state agencies, and faith-based groups to reduce dependency, cut costs, and restore dignity—without a formal office. That’s executive leadership without the trappings.
Crisis management record? Numerous. From hurricane coordination to messaging during statewide emergencies, she’s been a consistent, calming presence—and a logistical asset behind the scenes.
Major legislation? While not an elected official, her policy impact is measurable. Hope Florida led to real outcomes: fewer people on public assistance, more families connected to resources, and a replicable framework adopted across agencies. If not for the state House afraid of another DeSantis hampering their grift SB 1144 would have incorporated the Hope Florida program into an actual part of government. All without Casey being in government. If Byron Donalds could even come close to the same thing he’d be called a visionary leader, someone ready to take the mantle in Florida. Instead this accomplishment by Casey goes ignored, downplayed or worse yet attacked.
Policy initiative with measurable results? Yes. Hope Florida is widely recognized for reducing strain on public services while improving outcomes for vulnerable families—something no Byron Donalds initiative has ever come close to doing.
Demonstrated leadership in a natural disaster? Not just symbolic. She’s stood shoulder-to-shoulder with state officials, directly coordinating communication to displaced families and engaging with both relief workers and community leaders. No index cards, no megaphone—just action.
The Grown-Up in the Room
Florida doesn’t need a headliner. It needs a governor.
It needs someone who shows up in the trenches—not just on TV. Someone who knows how to manage a crisis without becoming one. Someone who doesn't confuse a press hit for a plan.
Ron DeSantis didn’t wait to be sworn in to act like a governor. Casey DeSantis never needed a title to lead. And Byron Donalds?
He’s still asking for the crayons—and wondering why the grown-ups won’t let him lead the class.
Leadership isn’t about being seen. It’s about being counted on.
Florida deserves more than a meme. It deserves a manager. And if we’re going to debate who should lead next, we should start by asking who’s been leading all along.
🐊 If You’re Tired of Slogans, Subscribe for Substance.
This isn’t just another newsletter shouting into the void. It’s a home for readers who still believe competence matters. If you’re done with meme candidates and ready to support writing that exposes grifters, highlights grown-ups, and demands better—then join us.
🔒 Become a paid subscriber to help build a smarter, saner conservative movement—one article, one takedown, one real leader at a time.
Florida deserves better. So does your inbox. Sign up today and lets build something bigger, badder and better than Con Inc.
Want more clarity in a world of clutter? I cover these topics—and the intellectual battles behind them—on Substack: The Rational Purview become a paid subsriber and help fight “The Swamp” with The Truth.
🟩 Subscribe.
🎙 Listen to Firing Lane.
☕ Support the anti-grift with a donation to Buy Me a Coffee.
🛍 Check out @MrsCroaky’s merch store.The fight for reason isn’t won in a day. But we can win it one argument at a time.